Mirada Bridge Rebuild - Half Moon Bay

From ActCoastal

Month May
Year 2021
Summary The Coastal Commission approved the San Mateo County Department of Public Works (DPW) application to replace the Mirada Road coastal trail bridge at the same location over Arroyo de en Medio Creek along with coastal armoring. The proposed project would include demolition of the concrete arch bridge, replacement of the pedestrian bridge, and installation of armoring on the north and south sides of the Arroyo to protect the bridge abutment areas. While the project has obvious public access benefits associated with restoring CCT access at this shoreline location, it also includes significant armoring that leads to adverse coastal resource impacts, including on beach and shoreline access now and over time.

Special Condition 2, the Public Access Mitigation Plan requires a new access stairway and access amenities. It is wholly insufficient to offset the coastal resource and ecological impacts of the proposed bridge rebuild and associated shoreline armoring. The Surfrider Foundation opposed the project and instead supported moving the trail inland as a better long-term solution in terms of financial cost and coastal resource impact. The Coastal Commission unanimously approved the permit.

Outcome Red Dot.png
Outcome Description Commissioners Donne Brownsey clarified through a series of questions to staff that armoring the coastal trail in this location may not necessarily be precedent setting. Commissioner Carole Groom motioned for approval and Commissioner Katie Rice seconded the motion.
Why You Should Care ActCoastal partners greatly support public access to and along the coast – but we must not destroy the very coast that we wish to visit and walk along. When we choose to armor a coastal trail instead of relocating it, we jeopardize the very purpose of access: enjoying our natural resources and natural shoreline processes.

Wise planning that will preserve our coast now and into the future requires us to make difficult decisions today.

Increased access to and along the coast is not sufficient to mitigate the impact of accelerated beach erosion and the complete loss of the coast itself. Coastal armoring should only be offset by creation of coastal habitat nearby or in the region. A living shoreline and/or managed retreat type project and sufficient financial resources to cover an appropriate project and would be the only sufficient mitigation. This will maintain habitat value as well as public access and recreational value.

Image Miradabridge.png
Decision Type Coastal Development Permit
Staff Recommendation Approval with conditions
Staff Report
Opposition to Project Surfrider Foundation
Coastal Act Policies Chapter 3

Voting Detail for Mirada Bridge Rebuild - Half Moon Bay

Individual vote detail for Issue: Mirada Bridge Rebuild - Half Moon Bay
Roberto UrangaBad Vote
Linda EscalanteBad Vote
Carole GroomBad Vote
Katie RiceBad Vote
Sara AminzadehBad Vote
Donne BrownseyBad Vote
Steve PadillaBad Vote
Mike WilsonBad Vote
Effie Turnbull-SandersBad Vote
Dayna BochcoBad Vote
Caryl HartBad Vote

Meeting Page

View Meeting Page for the meeting where this issue was discussed/voted on.